David had never heard the phrase performance management when he applied for a job as a food and beverage attendant at a hotel restaurant. At the interview, he was feeling nervous but hopeful, fidgeting with his fingers while wondering if he would make a good impression and whether, by the end of the day, he would have a job.
A few weeks earlier, the hotel’s Food and Beverage Director had been facing a different question, wondering whether the department could continue delivering the expected standard of service because, while weekend business had grown steadily, guest satisfaction scores had begun to decline during the busiest shifts as staff struggled to keep pace, and he decided that another attendant was needed.
The department reviewed the job description and posted the position. People began to apply, and David’s application was one of many. The restaurant manager wanted to look beyond technical skills, as he believed that qualities such as willingness to learn, teamwork, and a genuine commitment to guest service were essential for that job.
David got selected for the position and he was very happy that he had a job while the restaurant manager, looking at the big picture, believed that he had found someone who could grow with the department.
On his first day, David completed the hotel’s orientation. It introduced him to the organization, although he soon discovered that learning the job took much more than an orientation.
His manager welcomed him to the department, explained its daily operations and service standards, outlined his responsibilities, and arranged for him to begin departmental training.
David’s manager also introduced him to Maria, his onboarding buddy who showed him the unwritten side of the organization. She introduced him to coworkers, explained how departments worked together during busy periods, and shared practical advice that was not available in the orientation manual.
While Maria helped David understand the culture of the department, Daniel, who was the department’s certified trainer, focused on the technical aspects of the role. He guided David through departmental procedures, observed his progress over the following days, provided feedback, and ensured that he was ready to work independently.
A few weeks later, David’s manager called him into the office for their first performance conversation. They reviewed his role, discussed what would be expected of him, and agreed on performance goals for the coming months. As he left the meeting, David understood that doing his job well meant more than working hard. He now knew what success looked like and how his performance would be evaluated.
Each of David’s shift began with a brief team meeting where the manager shared operational priorities, updated the team on expected business levels, and highlighted any special events or guest needs. David soon realized that clear communication was part of everyday performance because priorities and expectations changed from one shift to the next.
As the days passed, his learning took place within the ordinary rhythm of each working day, as his supervisor observed the way he greeted guests before suggesting small refinements, as the chef showed him a more efficient way to organize service, and as Maria shared lessons drawn from her many years in hospitality. Each conversation, each observation, each demonstration, and each piece of immediate feedback became part of a continuous process through which he developed his skills while doing his work.
One evening, just before the restaurant closed, a family arrived after the kitchen had already begun cleaning, and although the parents apologized for arriving late, David noticed that their two young children looked tired, so, instead of turning them away, he asked the chef whether anything could still be prepared, and while the meal was being made, he brought out a box of Lego bricks to keep the children occupied and didn’t forget to check on them from time to time. There was no manager standing nearby to observe his actions, and no supervisor was present to direct what he should do.
The following morning, the General Manager received a handwritten letter from the family describing their experience. During the departmental meeting, the restaurant manager read the letter aloud. David looked uncomfortable and blushed as his coworkers applauded. Helping people had mattered more to him than receiving recognition, although he appreciated the acknowledgment.
As the months went by, David received many such letters of appreciation. He would receive guest comment cards and online reviews that praised his professionalism and kindness. David’s consistent guest service also earned him formal recognition through the hotel’s recognition programs.
His manager used each recognition as an opportunity to reinforce the service behaviours the department valued, and encouraged the rest of the team to learn from David’s example.
At times David stayed after his shift to help coworkers complete their work. He also volunteered to assist new employees who felt overwhelmed during busy weekends. When someone struggled, he stepped beside them without waiting to be asked. These habits gradually earned the trust and respect of his coworkers and showed leadership qualities that others began to notice.
David still remembered the day he misunderstood information about a guest’s food allergy. Luckily, the mistake was discovered before the meal reached the table, although the experience left him shaken. Rather than reprimanding him, his supervisor coached him, arranged additional training, and made the expectations clearer. The conversation focused on learning, and David never repeated the mistake. Looking back, he remained grateful for the way his supervisor had handled the situation.
Months later, for some unknown reason, David began arriving late for several morning shifts. His manager chose coaching before discipline, and reinforced the importance of arriving on time. When the lateness continued, a formal warning became necessary, just as good performance had been recognized throughout the year, poor performance also had consequences. David understood the seriousness of the situation and made the changes needed to arrive on time.
David noticed that whenever problems occurred, his manager first looked at how the work had been organised before discussing individual performance and considering staffing levels, training, equipment, and communication before anyone was held accountable.
Throughout the year, his manager maintained records of their performance conversations, development activities, recognition, and other significant events, so that each discussion and each milestone became part of an ongoing account of his progress instead of relying on memory at the end of the year. When the time came for his annual performance review, those records provided a clear foundation for the discussion, as they reviewed the goals they had set, considered his progress, identified new development opportunities, updated his objectives for the following year, and agreed on an individual development plan. By the end of the meeting, his manager asked a question that David had never seriously considered.
His manager asked whether David had ever considered becoming a supervisor to which David replied that he had, and this changed the direction of his career.
As part of his leadership development, David was selected for the hotel’s emerging leaders program. He attended leadership workshops, completed cross-training in several departments, shadowed supervisors, learned about scheduling and interviewing, and worked closely with the Food and Beverage Director, who became his leadership mentor.
Their conversations were different from the coaching David had received on the restaurant floor. They focused more on judgment, decision making, developing employees, and leading departments rather than serving tables.
When a supervisor position became available, several qualified employees were considered. David’s consistent performance and leadership potential earned him the promotion.
As David’s responsibilities changed, his role was no longer limited to the work he individually performed because it now included responsibility for the performance and development of other employees. He participated in recruitment, supported onboarding and training, established performance expectations, coached employees, recognized good performance, addressed performance concerns, completed performance reviews, and recommended employees for development opportunities.
One morning a newly hired food and beverage attendant arrived for orientation. David greeted the employee, introduced the departmental trainer, assigned an onboarding buddy, reviewed the training schedule, and smiled.
The new employee believed a new job had just begun. David knew something larger had begun. Years earlier, someone had done the very same for him. Without realizing it, the new employee had just entered the same performance management journey that had developed David’s own career.
Performance management had never been a single meeting, a single performance review, or a single disciplinary conversation. It was the continuous process that had guided David from applicant to employee, from employee to supervisor, and finally to the person responsible for leading and developing the next generation of team members.
Leave a Reply